J. Magi

Members

J. Magi had the most liked content!

64 Followers

Member Title
Get thee gone from my gate, thou jail-crow of Mandos
Pronouns
she/her
Location
Inside the Moon
Interests
Creating nigh incomprehensible lore for HG
Constantly changing my pfp because I'm mean like that
Silly little Finwëan guys

2.9k

J. Magi

Absolutely no one:

The comment section of every fantasy book recommendation video on the internet: READ PERCY JACKSON READ PERCY JACKSON PERCY JACKSON PERCY JACKSON READ IT READ PERCY JACKSON I'M BEGGING YOU
- August 7
- 4
- Report
1. Show previous comments 8 more
2. J. Magi
  
  I read Eragon once in middle school I think. It was alright, pretty basic I guess. My parents pointed out to me (because they had read it as well) that it was just the plot of the first Star Wars movie but medieval fantasy, and I can't really unsee that lol.
  
  August 7
  
  Report
3. The Bookwyrm
  
  Yeah.
  
  It's definitely not a bad series, just tropey.
  
  Nothing wrong with tropes if you do then right.
  
  But there is much out there that's better than Eragon.
  
  August 7
  
  1
  
  Report
4. Slowswift
  
  @The Bookwyrm Cruel to Percy Jackson. PJO holds up, imho, while Eragon doesn't.
  
  Also, most things are derivative, it's just about how skilled you are in the retelling. (If you think Tolkien or Lucas were wholly original, you've got another thing coming.)
  
  August 7
  
  1
  
  Report