J. Magi

Members

J. Magi had the most liked content!

64 Followers

Member Title
Get thee gone from my gate, thou jail-crow of Mandos
Pronouns
she/her
Location
Inside the Moon
Interests
Creating nigh incomprehensible lore for HG
Constantly changing my pfp because I'm mean like that
Silly little Finwëan guys

2.9k

J. Magi

I swear they'll never admit it but the Tolkien fandom can be so toxic sometimes good grief

Spoiler

ITS JUST AN ANIME MOVIE ITS NOT THE END OF THE WORLD GO READ THE BOOKS AND CRY FOR ALL I CARE THEY'RE NOT GOING ANYWHERE LET US NEW AUDIENCES ENJOY SOMETHING COOL ON THE SCREEN

Spoiler

a lot of people are complaining that they've made the protag a badass female princess instead of focusing on her dad who's a preexisting character but like

Haleth exists?

Luthien exists?

Eowyn exisits (and I think this character is more then likely based ON her)???

Spoiler

and I get that we're all a little sour about Rop, but the way I see, if it's bad it'll be fun to laugh at and I can at least enjoy the aesthetic, and if it's good then it's good!

anyway
- August 23
- 4
- Report
1. Show previous comments 1 more
2. J. Magi
  
  Yeah, I'd heard the director was famous. Another reason not to jump the gun on calling it trash.
  
  I don't know if I'll see it in theaters but it would be cool!
  
  August 23
  
  1
  
  Report
3. The cheeseman
  
  And also, Helm did in fact have a daughter. She's just never named, iirc. So she's not an invented character. There's also not a huge amount of information to go on anyway, so they have to make some stuff up.
  
  August 23
  
  1
  
  Report
4. J. Magi
  
  Oh, that's nice to know! I'll admit don't know much of the lore outside lotr and silmarillion shenanigans.
  
  August 23
  
  1
  
  Report